Thin-crust pizza on a metal tray at a sunlit neighborhood pizzeria patio table, with linen and soft Florida greenery behind.

Where to Get Pizza in Belleview This Thanksgiving Week

At 15, Kathy Funk took a job at a restaurant in the Paddock Mall run by Paul Dalto. She went on to manage several of his Gainesville restaurants, and in 2000 she came back to Belleview to manage Pasta Faire on US 441. Eight years later she bought it, and a year after that she opened a second Italian restaurant a few miles down 441 in Summerfield. 352today told the story in 2024.

That means the two longest-running independent pizza ovens on Belleview's stretch of 441 go back to the same owner, and they make very different pizzas. One makes New York pies and a thick Sicilian square. The other makes small, thin, well-done pies at 800 degrees. Pick the crust first, and the crust will tell you which of the two to drive to.

The Corner That Changed

Belleview Pizza & Italian Restaurant at 5428 SE Abshier Boulevard closed for good in June 2024 after more than 50 years. In March 2026 Ocala-News.com reported that the building was being converted into a Trulieve dispensary. We covered that building and the other restaurant changes along the corridor in our look at Belleview's 441 second acts. This post is about the ovens still working nearby.

Pasta Faire Bakes New York Pies and a Sicilian Square

Pasta Faire is at 10401 SE US Highway 441. Its pizza menu has New York-style pies in 12-inch and 16-inch sizes. It also has the "Faire Square," a thick-crust Sicilian. In her 352today interview, Funk described the kitchen's wood-burning brick oven pizzas and said, "Best pizza deal in Marion County."

The current pizza deals are on the restaurant's specials page. On Wednesdays, a 12-inch gourmet or build-your-own New York pizza is buy one, get one free, for dine-in or take-out. Every day, take-out orders of the large 16-inch New York pizza get the same buy-one-get-one deal. The free pie in both deals is one of equal or lesser value. For a family feeding a full table, that everyday 16-inch take-out offer is the number to know.

The menu goes far beyond pizza. Funk told 352today that "our menu has evolved over the last 30 years," and the rotisserie chickens are visible as soon as you walk in. She credited managing partner Brandon Magnuson and the long-term staff for keeping an independent restaurant going.

Francesco's Runs Its Oven at 800 Degrees

The Summerfield restaurant didn't start out as Francesco's. According to a 2014 Ocala Star-Banner story, the space in the Baylee Plaza on South US 441 was Taverna Red until the end of 2013. That year Francesco Esposito, then Pasta Faire's general manager, left on Christmas Eve to become Funk's partner in a fully Italian concept. "I gave myself a Christmas present," he told the paper. The remodel turned a side patio into the Garden Room, which has a working fireplace.

Francesco's is at 16770 South US 441, Suite 608, and its pizza is nothing like Pasta Faire's. The menu calls it "Napoletana style." The dough is hand-tossed and baked in an 800-degree stone-fired oven, and every pie is 10 inches, "thin, crispy, and well done." A plain pie with San Marzano tomato sauce and mozzarella is $11, and a cauliflower crust is $3 more. Among the specialty pies, the Margherita is $12, the Bronx Bomber with roasted red peppers, Italian sausage and pecorino is $13, and the Lasagna Pizza with ricotta, mini meatballs and sausage under house marinara is $15. The menu also has Roman-style pinsa.

The two kitchens can share an owner because their pizzas don't compete. A 16-inch New York pie is built to feed a table. A 10-inch well-done Napoletana is closer to one person's dinner. If half the house wants a big shared pie and the other half wants their own thin crust, the two restaurants cover both, a few miles apart on the same highway.

Zella's and Riccardo's

Two more independents fill in the New York side of the map. Zella's Pizzeria opened in 2023 on South US 441 toward Ocala. In 2024, Ocala-News.com named owner Hogan Richard-Heidorn and described New York-style pies with Hawaiian, meat lover's, barbecue chicken and chicken bacon ranch specialties. Its ordering site lists the address as 9360 S US Hwy 441, Suite 6. Build-your-own prices run from $10.99 for a 12-inch personal pie to $15.99 for a 16-inch medium and $17.99 for an 18-inch large, and a 12-inch gluten-free crust is $13.99.

The Zella's prices make a useful benchmark. A 16-inch at Zella's costs $15.99. The everyday take-out deal at Pasta Faire puts two 16-inch pies in the car for the price of one, so on a big take-out night the BOGO usually works out cheaper per slice, depending on toppings. For a single person or a couple, Zella's personal 12-inch and Francesco's 10-inch are within about a dollar of each other.

Riccardo's Restaurant, at 11783 US Highway 441, has been part of Belleview's Italian scene for more than a decade. The 2014 Star-Banner piece already called it "the newer Riccardo's" next to Pasta Faire. Ocala Style profiled it as a family-owned and family-run restaurant that sold pizza by the slice. On its online ordering storefront, a 14-inch cheese pizza is $19.50 and an 18-inch cheese is $20, so the larger size costs only 50 cents more. The storefront also lists a meat lovers pie at $22.75 and a white pizza. If you're ordering cheese, the 18-inch is the better value.

Wood Fire and a Beer List on SE 58th Avenue

Flying Boat Tap Room, at 9672 SE 58th Avenue, takes a different approach: homemade wood-fired pizza at a craft beer bar. The tap room's site lists Monday hours of 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. and 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. Wednesday through Saturday. It is closed Tuesdays. Sunday starts with brunch from 10 a.m. to noon, and the regular menu runs from noon to 8 p.m. Tuesday is the one night of the week it isn't an option. The site also says holiday hours can change and suggests calling or checking its Facebook page.

The Chains on 441

For a fast delivery or a late order, Five Star Pizza is at 10133 US 441, open 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sunday through Thursday and until 10 p.m. Friday and Saturday. It's a Florida chain with more than 20 locations, it makes hand-tossed dough fresh every day, and it does both delivery and pickup. Pizza Hut is down the road at 10738 SE US Highway 441.

Thanksgiving Week, Before and After the Turkey

With Thanksgiving on Thursday, Nov. 26, plenty of households will want pizza on Wednesday night while the kitchen is busy with prep, or on Friday, when nobody wants to cook again. Francesco's is also cooking the main event. 352today reported that the Summerfield restaurant is taking Thanksgiving takeout orders for pickup on Nov. 26, with turkey alongside its Italian dishes. Orders and menu details are by phone at 352-693-2008. Visit Ocala/Marion County's Thanksgiving dining roundup lists Pasta Faire as well. Hours at every restaurant here can shift during a holiday week, so call before you drive over on Wednesday, Thursday or Friday.

If you're new to the area, our Belleview neighborhood page has more about the town.

At The Table Team, we like the restaurants that keep a town's dinner tables full, and the Friday-after-Thanksgiving pizza order belongs on that list. If you're settling into Belleview and want more of our local picks, from pizza places to plumbers, schedule a consultation and we'll share our list.

Work With Us

From your first showing to the closing table, The Table Team delivers trusted guidance, local expertise, and a relationship that lasts well beyond the transaction.

Follow Us on Instagram